News Story

04 July 2008 21:41 BST

Need for 'father' in IVF treatment rejected by MPs

Tuesday, 20 May 2008 19:42

Campaigners say more very premature babies are surviving

Printer friendly version

MPs have voted down an amendment calling for both a "father and a mother" to be a condition for fertility treatment.

The amendment brought by Conservative MP Ian Duncan Smith was defeated by 292 votes to 217.

The legislation is expected to give lesbians and single women equal access to IVF treatment, with doctors only required to ensure that "supportive parenting" will be provided.

MPs have now begun debating and are due to vote around 22:00 BST tonight on whether the abortion limit should be lowered from its upper threshold of 24 weeks.

The vote comes as part of the controversial human fertilisation and embryology bill that is being debated in parliament.

Advocates of a lower limit say medical advances mean more very premature babies born before 24 weeks are surviving.

As such, they claim, on one hospital ward doctors could be aborting a 23-week-old fetus while on another ward they could be fighting to save a 23-week-old premature baby's life.

But other groups say the 24-week limit should be maintained as they believe there is no evidence to suggest the fetus is viable before this stage.

"If the time limit is reduced [today] abortion law in Britain will have reached the historic moment when it's cut loose from common consensus and medical opinion," said Family Planning Association (FPA) chief executive Julie Bentley.

Liberal Democrat MP Dr Evan Harris added: "There has been a campaign of misinformation, assertion and irrelevant information about the abortion time limit led by very well funded organisations opposed to all abortion.

"Sadly, the evidence shows that it simply isn't the case that wanted babies born below 24 weeks are more likely to survive. It is a cruel deception on parents with pre-term babies. It would be astonishing if parliament took a view against the united approach of all the relevant medical institutions." End of story

More headline news...

Also In The News

MPs back hybrid embryo research
MPs have voted in favour of allowing scientists to create hybrid embryos for research that supporters say could bring advances in medical treatment. Full Story

China in mourning over earthquake
China has begun three days of national mourning, a week after the devastating earthquake struck that killed more than 30,000 people. Full Story

Burma to accept cyclone relief coordination
Burma's military rulers are to allow neighbouring countries to coordinate its relief efforts for victims of Cyclone Nargis. Full Story

News Story

Need for 'father' in IVF treatment rejected by MPs

Also In The News

MPs back hybrid embryo research

China in mourning over earthquake

Burma to accept cyclone relief coordination