Doctors question safety of self-testing medical kits

Health tests and scans for the 'worried well' may do more harm than good
Health tests and scans for the 'worried well' may do more harm than good
 
 

Tuesday, 11, Mar 2008 11:11

Doctors and scientists have raised concerns today about the safety of self-testing medical kits for the 'worried well'.

A group of doctors and the Sense About Science organisation say the tests could cause potential damage and are calling for a national system to evaluate laboratory tests.

They are concerned that despite the huge growth in established laboratory tests and marketing of testing to healthy people there is no system to provide doctors or patients with evidence on performance and usefulness.

A report published today by Sense About Science with the Association of Clinical Biochemistry, the PHG Foundation and the Royal College of Pathologists says most tests were not designed for well people and are not researched or adequately regulated.

It adds that tests are only one part of diagnosis and that they can cause harm, especially in well people.

Presenting the report at parliament today, its authors say a national system is needed to evaluate diagnostic tests along with a publicly accessible database to provide evidence of performance and usefulness.

They argue that policymakers need to decide who is responsible for gathering evidence and meeting the costs.

Professor Peter Furness, vice president of the Royal College of Pathologists, said: "Market forces only work if consumers can judge the quality of what they are getting.

"But even professionals find it difficult to assess the quality and usefulness of medical tests.

"To base an important decision only on one-sided marketing hype is surely a recipe for disaster. We need an independent system to evaluate all these tests, with its results published and easily available to everyone."


Grand National runners that meet the requirements in 2011

There are going to be forty Grand National Runners this Saturday all lining up at Aintree and picking the Grand National winner is always a difficult thing to do.

Gold Cup 2011 odds point to Imperial Commander as the winner

The latest Gold Cup Odds are not only important because they represent how much you can win on the race.

Cheltenham Gold Cup runners and best bets

Fourteen runners have been declared for the Cheltenham Gold Cup 2011 and the question on many people's lips will be.

Cheltenham Gold Cup 2011 runners and odds

The Cheltenham Gold Cup Runners have now been confirmed. As long as there are no late withdrawals there will be 14 Cheltenham Gold Cup runners.

Cheltenham Festival stats and tips should mean more winnings and winners

The Cheltenham Festival 2011 gets underway next week and one of the most popular methods of picking Cheltenham Festival winners is not only to follow tips, but also to take notice of important Cheltenham Festival Stats.

Cheltenham Races odds and tips suggest proven Cheltenham form is key

At long last The Cheltenham Festival 2011 is here and whether punters are going to the course or watching it on TV, everyone will be looking for winning tips for Cheltenham.

Cheltenham races odds and tips can help you find 50/1 winner at the festival

The Cheltenham Festival 2011 gets underway on Tuesday. The highlight of Cheltenham Races on the opening day will be the Champion Hurdle and three days of brilliant racing will follow Tuesday's action.



We're mobile!

Get news, sport and entertainment on your mobile. Text inthenews to 84010 or go to http://m.inthenews.co.uk. There is no charge for this service but the SMS will be charged at your standard operator rate.